Numismatic Grading for Silver Coins

Posted by on October 26, 2011

When collecting and investing in numismatic silver coins understanding condition grades is as important as knowing the year and place the coin was struck. The following general information about numismatic grading is applicable to NGC grading, PCGS grading, and ANACS grading.

1885-O Morgan Silver Dollar

1885-O Morgan Silver Dollar

The current generally used grading system is an outgrowth of the demands of the market place.  A hundred years ago coins were considered to fall into three states of condition: “Good” (well used), “Fine” (used), and “Very Fine” (hardly used).  However with the increase in collectors, auctions, and prices a better way of describing the condition was needed.  Especially with the ever widening price difference between the “Very Fine” condition silver coins and “Fine”.   This also caused the “Very Fine” grade to be considered too simplistic and incapable of describing a coin with no ware, very little ware - and then those with a bit more.  A standard of grading and an in-depth stratification of what those grades meant had to come into being.

The grade of a coin is determined by how much wear a coin shows. This is first evident on the highest surfaces of the coin. These vary from series to series, but in general the coin's detail is less and less evident as a coin is worn by handling. Each part of a coin is considered when it is graded. Each coin is considered to have three sides: the Obverse side; (head) usually has a portrait/bust image and year of mintage, the Reverse side; (tail) has the value/denomination, and the third side is called the Edge; plain, grooved, or ornamented.

5x Bausch & Lomb Sight Savers Compact Pocket Coin Magnifying Glass Loupe
5x Bausch & Lomb Sight Savers Compact Pocket Coin Magnifying Glass Loupe
$12.95
Time Remaining: 8d 19h 49m
Buy It Now for only: $12.95
Best Quality 500g Bullion Coin Scale + 60x Powered LED Loupe Silver Mercury Dime
Best Quality 500g Bullion Coin Scale + 60x Powered LED Loupe Silver Mercury Dime
$42.30
Time Remaining: 18d 3h 34m
Buy It Now for only: $42.30
DUAL 60x / 30x LED Lighted Loupe Magnifying Glass Great 4 Coins Tokens Currency
DUAL 60x / 30x LED Lighted Loupe Magnifying Glass Great 4 Coins Tokens Currency
$8.95
Time Remaining: 19d 5h 21m
Buy It Now for only: $8.95
40x LED Lighted Loupe Magnifying Glass Great for ALL Coins, Tokens, Paper Money
40x LED Lighted Loupe Magnifying Glass Great for ALL Coins, Tokens, Paper Money
$7.95
Time Remaining: 21d 16h 35m
Buy It Now for only: $7.95
1843 & 1857 Seated Liberty Silver Half Dollar 20x Loupe ****UNIQUE****LOOK****
1843 & 1857 Seated Liberty Silver Half Dollar 20x Loupe ****UNIQUE****LOOK****
$79.00
Time Remaining: 13d 20h 50m
Buy It Now for only: $79.00
30x LED Lighted Loupe Magnifying Glass Great 4 Coins!!!
30x LED Lighted Loupe Magnifying Glass Great 4 Coins!!!
$8.95
Time Remaining: 3d 13h 34m
Buy It Now for only: $8.95
1841 Silver Half Dime XF Extra Fine Details Loupe Attached
1841 Silver Half Dime XF Extra Fine Details Loupe Attached
$25.00
Time Remaining: 20d 22h 18m
Buy It Now for only: $25.00
Very Bright Lighted LED 40X Scope or Loupe for Coins & Small details like stamps
Very Bright Lighted LED 40X Scope or Loupe for Coins & Small details like stamps
$12.95
Time Remaining: 27d 18h 1m
Buy It Now for only: $12.95
10-30x & 21MM Jewelers Loupe w/ Case  ~Dealer Lot~ Last Lot
10-30x & 21MM Jewelers Loupe w/ Case ~Dealer Lot~ Last Lot
$31.50
Time Remaining: 20d 11m
Buy It Now for only: $31.50

The Obverse and Reverse share characteristics: the Field is the flat portion of the coin, the Relief is the raised portion (design) of the coin; the Rim is the raised area running around these sides, the Legend refers to the inscriptions of value and country of mintage.

Grading for wear as a state of condition is now widely done using the 70 point Sheldon Scale grading system, developed in 1948 by Dr. William M Sheldon and is in general use today.

MS   60-70              Mint State (Uncirculated)

-no wear is apparent at all although there maybe some contact marks and dulling of the original luster.

AU   50, 53, 55, 58     About Uncirculated

-all detail is readily apparent with only slight signs of wear.

XF   40, 45             Extremely Fine

-lightly worn but the relief is bold and details mostly apparent.

VF   20, 25, 30, 35     Very Fine

-moderately worn, the relief is fully apparent some details are worn.

F    12, 15             Fine

-well worn, some of the relief’s details show.

VG   8, 10              Very Good

-the relief images are worn but clear.

G    4, 6               Good

-the relief images are outlined but without details, the rim maybe worn away in spots.

AG   3                  About Good

-the relief is apparent but some of the outlines are worn flat and obscured.

FA   2                  Fair

-the mint and date are barely legible, but the series is apparent.

PR   1                  Poor

-these heavily worn coins are barely identifiable as to their series and may not have a visible date or mint mark.

The three top rated coin grading services are:

ANACS: American Numismatic Association Certification Service

NGC; Numismatic Guarantee Corporation

PCGS; Professional Coin Grading Service

Photograde: Official Photographic Grading Guide for United States Coins
Photograde: Official Photographic Grading Guide for United States Coins
List Price: $12.95
Sale Price: $6.69
You save: $6.26 (48%)
  Eligible for free shipping!
Whitman Encyclopedia of U.S. Paper Money
Whitman Encyclopedia of U.S. Paper Money


4 Responses to Numismatic Grading for Silver Coins

  1. Jamey nyc

    Interesting banter I’ve bookmarked the page on Digg.com under “Grading Numismatic Silver Coins SilverCoins.Ag”. So hopefully our friends can give you a visit. Cheers!

  2. Ambre Le Breton

    Bonjour.

    Tout d’abord merci pour le petit message sur mon site.
    Je suis permi de visiter le votre puisque c’est de bonne pratique dans les échange de lien.
    Je trouve votre site très intéressant et sobre.
    Je me rend compte en visitant les liens des message que l’on me laisse sur mon site que nous manquons tous en majorité de la fonction multilangue, et que malgrès la traduction offerte par les moteurs de recherche, le rendu n’est pas toujour très bien traduit. je n’ai pas encore mis en place cette solution mais je vais y penser sérieusement.
    Merci de vous être intéresser à mon site l’espace d’une visite.
    Cordialement.
    Ambre.LB56

  3. panji

    nice article..:)

  4. Evonne Emmerling

    I like this site so much, saved to bookmarks .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.